diff --git a/Controller/SubsciberController.php b/Controller/SubsciberController.php
index 99a72f892f42f557ccf1a436ec3b22e86ac4d775..9614b60c99a1551da4ad6fd5cdda6b56811c2250 100644
--- a/Controller/SubsciberController.php
+++ b/Controller/SubsciberController.php
@@ -207,17 +207,9 @@ class SubsciberController
       ($req->getQuery("limit") > 0 ? $req->getQuery("limit") : SubsciberController::DEFAULT_LIMIT)
       : SubsciberController::DEFAULT_LIMIT;
     $data = SubsciberController::fetchSubscriptions($page, $limit, $user_id, $req->db);
-    if ($data === false) {
-      // return $res->json([
-      //   "status"=>"failed",
-      //   "message"=>"fetch operations failed",
-      //   "data"=>[],
-      //   "errors"=>curl_error($ch)
-      // ]);      
+    if ($data === false) { 
       return $res->redirect("/", 500);
     }
-
-    //   $data = json_decode($output,true)["data"];
     //fetch max page
     $fetcher = new FetchAPI(getenv("REST_API"));
     $param = [
@@ -225,7 +217,7 @@ class SubsciberController
     ];
     $rest_key = getenv("REST_KEY");
     $headers = [
-      "X-API-KEY" => $rest_key
+      "X-API-KEY: $rest_key"
     ];
     $output  = $fetcher->get("/singers/max-page", $param, $headers);
     $total_page = 1;